Am I Dead?
← All postmortems

Week of 10/19/2026

85% of Players Kept Sondheim Alive. He Wasn't.

1,796 players, 128 perfect rounds, and a wager column that nearly split down the middle: 47% at 1x, 47% at 3x, and just 6% in the middle. Players who went bold earned it — 3x accuracy hit 83% against 72% on 1x — and the bold-and-right rate landed at 51%. The week's average came in at 77%, which looks respectable until you see what Portrait of Stephen SondheimStephen Sondheim did to the people who went 3x on the wrong side.

By the Numbers

Total guesses
17,960
Average accuracy
77%
Hardest celebrity
Portrait of Stephen SondheimStephen Sondheim (15%)
Easiest celebrity
Portrait of Jennifer LopezJennifer Lopez (100%)
Biggest upset
Portrait of Stephen SondheimStephen Sondheim
Players this week
1,796
Perfect rounds
128
Wager mix
1× 47% · 2× 6% · 3× 47%

What stood out

Portrait of Chuck DChuck D landed at 47% accuracy on 277 guesses — 47% alive, 53% dead. He's alive, which means the slight majority had it wrong. Right behind him, Portrait of Rita MorenoRita Moreno drew 46% alive calls on 208 guesses. She's also alive, so the majority went the wrong way there too. Two living celebrities, both called deceased by a thin majority. The field was guessing, and it shows.

Portrait of Chuck DHow 277 players guessed Chuck D
Alive
47%
Dead
53%

Portrait of Tim CurryTim Curry added another layer of noise: 55% alive calls on 244 guesses, 45% accuracy. He's deceased. And Portrait of Lee Harvey OswaldLee Harvey Oswald pulled 62% alive calls — 38% accuracy — which is a number I genuinely didn't expect on someone from the 1960s historical bracket.

On the far end: Portrait of Jennifer LopezJennifer Lopez at 100% on 208 guesses. Not a single wrong answer. She was the week's only clean sweep, and the field needed it.

Portrait of Stephen Sondheim
musician
Stephen Sondheim
1950s-2020s · Americandeceased

He revolutionized musical theater with complex lyrics and innovative musical structures, and was also an avid puzzle creator who contributed crosswords to New York Magazine.

85% of players called Portrait of Stephen SondheimStephen Sondheim alive. He's deceased. That's 15% accuracy on 297 guesses — worst on the board by a meaningful margin, and the week's biggest upset. The 1950s–2020s theater composer ran harder against players than anything else this week, and with 47% of all bets going 3x, a substantial chunk of those wrong answers cost the maximum. The next-hardest miss was Portrait of Toby KeithToby Keith at 25% accuracy — 75% alive calls — which makes the gap between first and second about ten points. Sondheim wasn't close.

Portrait of Stephen SondheimHow 297 players guessed Stephen Sondheim
Alive
85%
Dead
15%

Honorable mentions

  • Portrait of Toby KeithToby Keith at 25% — 75% of players called the country musician alive. He's deceased. Second-hardest miss, and not a near thing.
  • Portrait of Angela DavisAngela Davis at 26% — 74% dead calls on 274 guesses. She's alive. Make of that what you will.
  • Portrait of Caetano VelosoCaetano Veloso at 32% and Portrait of Gao XingjianGao Xingjian at 31% — both alive, both dragged under 35% by a field that leaned the wrong way on both.